Gestures are not better for me and my situation. Please stop suggesting that I work against my better interests.
They are objectively slower and less precise, just to start with.
xcjs
joined 2 years ago
Third party launcher and three button navigation?
I'll have issues after taking a screenshot and navigating back - I just get a non-responsive black screen sometimes except for the navigation buttons. Those are partially unresponsive, and I have to tap them chaotically to get rid of the black screen.
I think the whole Android system navigation has been broken since Google started rolling it into the Pixel Launcher.
It depends on how often and how quickly you use the task switch button. I use it to rapidly switch between two apps frequently by double tapping the button and trigger it multiple times a day still. Google still recognizes it as an open bug.
To note, this occurs with the three button layout, so the fact that you're not having a problem is expected.
I'll only switch from the three button layout if I'm forced to. The gesture based navigation is slower and less precise.
It is not nearly a replacement for me.
It's been a constant thorn in my side on my Pixel 4 XL, my Pixel 6 Pro, and now my Pixel 8 Pro.
I confirmed with a friend that it still occurs on her Pixel 9 Pro XL.
They still haven't fixed the task switch button from the three button layout becoming non-functional after four years: https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/204650736
It's a byproduct of the home and task switch button now being managed by the Pixel Launcher regardless of which launcher you use. The animation delay makes it so the button becomes inactive and won't be made active again until the Pixel Launcher is killed or the phone restarted.
From my perspective, Google is losing interest in maintaining Android at all.
Not the person you're debating (and I'm on your side here), but what's up with all the revisionist history going on lately?
"This thing you're arguing for was never the intent."
Then what was the intent you dimwit?
And they never have an answer aside from acting like it was some grave oversight that was only recently caught as a mistake.
That is exactly a function of a jury.
"What you say disagrees with my world view, so I'm just going to pretend you're crazy and your words don't make sense."
I've had this exact tactic used against me - it's very transparent when used and weakens your position.
You're the second person in this thread to try convincing me to switch.
I use the app switcher constantly. I'm using it now to jump between my Lemmy client and YouTube. It works. It's fast. The back navigation also interferes with productivity apps, many of which still use a drawer. I use those apps constantly as well.
Gesture navigation will never be a proper use case for me.