It usually comes down to rings. If they've got one, its the 3000 hit club for baseball level.
Lack of ring has kept Ken Anderson out and I absolutely think Rivers is HOF level but some are gonna hold that against him
maltzy
joined 2 years ago
First non primetime Bengals game I've gotten this season and one of those primetime games was the "other MNF" on Espn Ocho or some shit.
I'll add a couple more
Odell Thurman - dude was all world in his only year in the NFL, looked like the next elite LB and never played another season because he was stupid.
David Pollack - looked like he was a pure playmaker after his rookie year. He was very good in the playoff game against the steelers. Gets a bone in his neck broken first game of his second season, never plays a down again.
We lost two great defenders at the same time of Palmer's injury, that felt like a curse