andrewrgross

joined 2 years ago
MODERATOR OF
[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 3 points 3 weeks ago (5 children)

The ending of this is bad. I don't know why they did that. I really want to see Ironheart eventually become an actual superhero, but I don't know what is going to happen to her now.

She never actually became a superhero. She never actually developed a sense of justice or a desire to do good. She never actually took to helping anyone besides her self. And then at the end, she just makes a deal with a demon to resurrect her best friend? For an origin story, this felt more like a retirement. She has no public persona or identity or motivating purpose or network. At least Kate Bishop met an Avenger and declared an intent to fight crime. But what kind of future adventures are we expecting to get with Ironheart, either solo or in an ensemble? It was a superhero origin story where no superhero originated. And it's made worse by my concerns that we'll even see this character in another show or movie. Is this just her whole arc? Is Ironheart in the MCU done now?

What a bummer. I really hope they correct course. Make this a dream or something. I want real Ironheart.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 3 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago) (3 children)

Yeah, I'm just trying to imagine the reactions. Her mom should be pissed that she revived Natalie but didn't ask for Gary too. And Xavier is gonna be all over the place. And then of course we have no idea how Natalie is going to feel about it.

Also, how do you get a drivers license or a social security card? Do you just say, 'Well you see, I was resurected by magic. Yes, my death certificate is 100% valid. It was not a mistake. I was reconstituted from nothing by the devil in a pact made by my best friend for her soul. Yes, really. Yes, I mean this literally, not figuratively. No, no super-science or time travel. No, not THE devil, but yes and actual demon. My original body? Well that's kind of macabre. I hadn't thought about it. I think since I reappeared in a summoning circle there's about a 50-50 chance that either my corpse is still in the cemetery or an urn or that it disappeared at the same time my living body appeared. I don't know. Age? I don't know, um, it's been 5 years, so why don't you just leave my birthday unchanged. Blipped? Hmm, I don't recall. It hasn't come up so I don't really know if I was blipped or not. Lets say yes, that seems to make things easier, right? Thanks.'

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 8 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago)

It was such a strange choice, because she'd made the wrong decision at literally every point. So having her do so at the last moment felt like the opposite of narrative arrival.

It was like listening to someone tell a joke that goes 'A guy goes into the bar and asks for . Then a second guy goes into the bar and asks for . Finally, a third guy goes into the bar. The bartender asks what he wants. And he asks for .'

It makes no sense, structurally. It was a fall from grace story with no fall.

Also, why are they doing this to a character we're supposed to like? They are really doing Riri Williams so dirty. We all so badly want to like Ironheart, and she's got such an almost impossible challenge ahead of her because she's going to invariably have to weather comparisons to Robert Downey Jr.'s Iron Man. And I can forgive trying and failing, but at the end it seems they're not even going to try? They're just going to make her a heel? That's fucking nuts.

Also, what is their plan for this? This show and character don't seem nearly strong enough to be essential viewing or a tent-pole storyline. But if they don't get a second season or make her a major character in films then I'm worried this is the end of Riri. If this is the complete Ironheart ark we get from Disney and Feige then it's going to be one of the biggest television betrayals since Wanda Maximov was turned evil and then shoved unceremoniously off to her death. Why do this? The stories are already disappointing so many fans. Why make choices that make it worse?

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 2 points 3 weeks ago

If I can try to build on this constructively, I think sometimes conversations about diversity in media become a little bit too categorical, and dare I say overly race-focused.

I want to see characters like Riri Williams because her lived experience is different than that of Tony Stark, Steve Rogers, Bruce Banner, and so on. It's not just that she's got melanin. It's that her age and place of birth and the resources available to her and the obstacles that she faces are different from those of those other characters. It makes stories fresh. It gives people from that background more media with which they can more closely relate, and it gives people who aren't from that background an ability to better relate to and appreciate the experiences of those who are.

I just feel like this sometimes doesn't get acknowledged enough. I'm not looking for more "black people". I'm just looking for more people. And black people happen to be among many kinds of people we haven't seen as much of in these stories so far.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 2 points 3 weeks ago

I've been very disappointed. My brother shared a podcast with me that was talking about it, and I thought they captured a lot of my feelings very well: https://www.theringer.com/podcasts/midnight-boys/2025/06/26/ironheart-episodes-1-3-and-fantastic-four-final-trailer-reactions-the-midnight-boys

They came at it -- like I do -- from a place of love. I loved Riri in Wakanda Forever, I love the idea of the character, I really like the actors and I really want to like this show. Ultimately, I think it has not been a good show, but I do believe it was made with love, and I absolutely want everyone involved to get more chances to make this better.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 4 points 3 weeks ago

It's very weird. It should've been listed for $44 million.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 1 points 3 weeks ago

This was a better episode than the last few for me because there was less story. The story has been bothering me for making no sense, and it still does bother me and makes no sense here, but at least we see some fighting which gives us a break.

That said, WTF is wrong with Riri's support system? Her Mom is like 'This is our home!': c'mon! Get the fuck outta town! You're gonna lose your daughter! You lost your husband to street violence and you clearly don't get how this works! Get to safety! The solution to all these problems is not more powered armor! And Xavier: how did he come around on the Natalie AI? He's right! Riri is wrong! Why are the writers of this taking her side??

Lastly, my biggest issue: the portrayal of Zeke when he finds out he's been turned into a drone is... a choice. They went with comedy? He's issuing apologies while his body is used to kill people? This is the greatest form of violation. It reads like the old 80's comedies like Porkies or Revenge of the Nerds back when writers rooms seemed to think non-consensual sex was a great source of comedy. I don't get how the writers chose to go this way, and the director, and the actor. No one at any point said, 'This isn't gonna play on screen. This is pure distilled horror and the character is reading as embarrassed instead of desperately wanting to be dead.'

I will finish the show and keep hoping for a better version of this character. I like Ironheart and I like Dominique Thorne, but this show is killing me slowly.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 2 points 3 weeks ago

I'm sorry, but I've got more.

Parker and the gang are like, 'Wow, sure is weird that a stranger's gear showed up in our heist. Seems like Riri had an outside partner she didn't tell us about, and also brought some gear she didn't tell us about to the mission that wasn't part of her assigned job. And also snuck off to the room where John was killed. I guess the world is funny like that!'

The story doesn't even need magic to explain why Parker knows Riri killed John. What they do need to explain is why Riri would imagine that they all wouldn't know that she killed John after her betrayal and fingerprints are on the evening news.

Also: this show has too many faceless deaths. Parker in particular has murdered a lot of faceless guards in cold blood, and Riri is very okay with that. Riri, you should be in jail. You are so guilty of those people's deaths. Maybe you can feign ignorance before it happens, but afterwards if you show up to the gang meeting when you know this is the kill-kill kind of street gang and not the simple muggings and beatings kind, that's on you. You're signing your approval to this guy making widows and orphans. Those security guards aren't AIM or Hydra, those are blue collar Chicagoans who have been the victims of inexcusable violence.

This show needs a superhero to fight Riri, because she's a bad, bad, person.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 2 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago) (1 children)

I'm sorry to be the guy who kvetches about everything, but as much as I want to like this show, I don't get how the writers can not see how flimsy and senseless all of this is.

Why didn't Ezekial immediately turn Riri in for a plea bargain? Having some weird rubber is not a crime. He can just say that he gave it to Riri with no idea what she was planning, which is true and almost certainly be out on bail that afternoon. Does richboy not have a lawyer or anything?

Why did he break out? Again, where the fuck is this dude's lawyer? Don't trust the magical man in the cloak! Did you learn nothing from your last betrayal??

And then you go so far as to let strangers do crackhead backyard surgery on you?? What is this guy's fucking malfunction? It's such a flaw in the writing that he appears to have no friends or family at all. He doesn't get out of jail and find anyone he can trust? He just learned how untrustworthy strangers are and he's lying down in a surgery machine with a bunch of creepy criminals who look and sound just like Riri at the controls and he's going to let them slice and dice him with no protection or anyone he trusts even watching? This guy is going to be lucky to wake up, let alone wake up without his brain in a jar.

Also, the sorcerers are like, 'Riri, this is dangerous as hell! Any smart or caring person would immediately dispose of it! Good luck finding such a person!'

If someone brought me something like that, I'd immediately take care of it. Why did they make it her problem? Aside from obviously the plot seems to demand a ton of stuff happening with no justification at all.

Follow-up mention to Riri introducing that guy to his dead sister's AI hologram. Bro, what the fuck did you expect?

Also, Riri's friends and family suck. Intervene! What kind of mom puts up with this? What her family should be saying is 'Sweety, I've been very forgiving of you having obviously joined gang as soon as you got kicked outta school but now you're clearly tits deep in high-level supervillain bullshit. Go call the Avengers or get the fuck outta my house.' And: 'Oh my god I thought I was having trouble healing from the death of Natalie but you've won the trauma olympics. Here's your medal now pack your bags for therapy and not the voluntary kind.'

Fuck, it makes me mad and sad that they're doing this with a good character in a show that had so much potential.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 20 points 4 weeks ago (2 children)

Also, not only do they rely on "just vision", crucially they rely on real-time processing without any memory or persistent mapping.

This, more than anything else is what bewilders me most.

They could map an area, and when observing a construction hazard save that data and share it with other vehicles so they know when route setting or anticipate the object. Not they don't. If it drives past a hazard and goes around the block it has to figure out how to navigate the hazard again with no familiarity. That's so foolish.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 5 points 1 month ago

Oof. Everything about this bill feels like having a car driven over you slowly. Fuck.

[–] andrewrgross@slrpnk.net 38 points 1 month ago (4 children)

This is a genuine concern that we should recognize.

I'm about 99% confident it isn't, but considering it is the kind of caution we should all be exercising these days.

 

There was a post on Reddit that praised the ubiquitous "Dear Alice" commercial, and inevitably a comment criticizing praise for a commercial. This led to me to wonder more about who it was that made this famous solarpunk advertisement. The answer is an animation studio called The Line. I went looking at some of their other work, and came across this interesting demo short for what appears to be a proof of concept or pilot for a solarpunky animated monster hunting series.

I don't love the heavy use of guns. But setting that aside, I think the art is interesting. I'm fascinated to see what people are doing with the artistic and conceptual toolset solarpunk offers, and I think this is a use case that I wouldn't mind seeing more of.

Unfortunately, this demo is as far as the project went. But I'm happy to see that the folks at The Line appear to have some broader interest in solarpunk, and I hope they keep putting it into practice in unique ways.

 

Springfield, Ohio became suddenly famous nationally when Trump claimed that an influx of Haitian migrants were devouring residents' pets. I went looking to see what the town is experiencing from the perspective of local news, and it looks surprising nuanced.

It appears that the town saw a rapid influx of migrants fleeing violence in Haiti. The town has since experienced a strain in its ability to function in notable ways because of the population shock. The issues include a sudden reduction in the housing supply and an increase in traffic and inexperienced drivers. One particularly bad traffic accident killed a child during a school bus crash.

The city government has seemed to largely avoid blaming new arrivals themselves. However they've expressed a sense of betrayal towards Biden and the federal government for granting thousands of people entry into the country without appearing to recognize any responsibility for helping them resettle or aiding their destination cities in accommodating them. Additionally, they've begun investigating local businesses which they suspect used the expansion of visas for Haitians seeking asylum as an opportunity to seek out low-cost workers while concealing their role in creating a population shock for which the city was unprepared.

I must say that I think the city government makes a reasonable point: those of use who want to offer foreign visitors safety and dignity in American must also demand that our government takes responsibility for helping them relocate to a town in which is expecting their arrival and has been aided in making that arrival successful.

 
 

cross-posted from: https://slrpnk.net/post/13236888

Not givin' up

 

Not givin' up

 

cross-posted from: https://slrpnk.net/post/13156086

Parable of the Sower is such a good book.

First, it's interesting that it starts right about now. The book starts in mid-2024, and even mentions that its an election year. That was a fascinating experience to read a scifi book in the moment in time in which it is set. It still feels like it takes place about 20 years in the future. It was written 31 years ago, so politically things have seemed to move as many steps forward as backward. It seems like a lot of things have not gotten better and worse than when Butler wrote it, so in some sense I feel like I'm looking at it as a near future in the same way as when it was written a generation ago. I guess I'm glad things didn't go as badly as in the story, but it's rough that the looming threat from 30 years ago feels the same distance away now as then.

Second, it's painful to read. Although the events described in the book haven't happened in the book's setting -- California -- the social collapse and migrations described have happened in Honduras, Gaza, Yemen, and certainly others I'm not aware of. It was really hard to read that and know that it was already real somewhere.

Third, as a solarpunk novel -- and really as general fiction -- it feels like it should be part of a high school curriculum. It's really well written and an engrossing read. Since publishing Fully Automated, I often relate solarpunk stories to that game. What might I have added to the game if I'd read this before? How well does it naturally fit? One thing that struck me is that her emerging in-world faith -- Earthseed -- reminds me quite a bit of elements of Seekerism, a new faith tradition in Fully Automated. I wish I'd known and included direct references to Earthseed, but it's nice when the game has alignment with great works that I wasn't directly familiar with.

Has anyone else read this? What do you folks think?

 

Parable of the Sower is such a good book.

First, it's interesting that it starts right about now. The book starts in mid-2024, and even mentions that its an election year. That was a fascinating experience to read a scifi book in the moment in time in which it is set. It still feels like it takes place about 20 years in the future. It was written 31 years ago, so politically things have seemed to move as many steps forward as backward. It seems like a lot of things have not gotten better and worse than when Butler wrote it, so in some sense I feel like I'm looking at it as a near future in the same way as when it was written a generation ago. I guess I'm glad things didn't go as badly as in the story, but it's rough that the looming threat from 30 years ago feels the same distance away now as then.

Second, it's painful to read. Although the events described in the book haven't happened in the book's setting -- California -- the social collapse and migrations described have happened in Honduras, Gaza, Yemen, and certainly others I'm not aware of. It was really hard to read that and know that it was already real somewhere.

Third, as a solarpunk novel -- and really as general fiction -- it feels like it should be part of a high school curriculum. It's really well written and an engrossing read. Since publishing Fully Automated, I often relate solarpunk stories to that game. What might I have added to the game if I'd read this before? How well does it naturally fit? One thing that struck me is that her emerging in-world faith -- Earthseed -- reminds me quite a bit of elements of Seekerism, a new faith tradition in Fully Automated. I wish I'd known and included direct references to Earthseed, but it's nice when the game has alignment with great works that I wasn't directly familiar with.

Has anyone else read this? What do you folks think?

2
submitted 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago) by andrewrgross@slrpnk.net to c/music@slrpnk.net
 

cross-posted from: https://slrpnk.net/post/13067768

I finally got around to making a playlist of the music used to score the starter campaign, Fully Automated: Regulation!

I think it's a collection of real bangers. I hope that for people who haven't played these stories, this might give an enticing taste of what to expect. And for people who might've played, perhaps it takes you back to some memorable moments.

Demonstration of Power

  • The stakeout: “This DJ” by Warren G
  • Fight scene!: “Dare to be Stupid”, covered by The Cybertronic Spree
  • Roll credits: “Fine”, by Lemon Demon

Psychonautica

  • Opening Sparing match: “Champion” by Buju Banton
  • Entering neurospace: “Just dropped in” by Kenny Roger
  • The mindscape: “Ghandi, Dalai Lama, Your Lord & Savior J.C.” by André 3000
  • Dance battle: “Do the Damn Thing” by Rupee
  • The Bathhouse: “Ants to You, Gods to Who?” by André 3000
  • Android assault: “Robot Rock” by Daft Punk
  • Synthesizing the cure: “The Oligo Separation Verse” and “Analytical Gangster” by True Speak
  • Roll credits: “Pony” by Deluxe

Piece of Mind

  • Surf Intro: “Cecilia Ann” by The Pixies
  • Fighting back: “Headshot” by she
  • Starting the investigation: “No Time for Dreaming” by Charles Bradley & Menahan Street Band
  • Sneaking around: “The Sensual Woman” by The Herbaliser
  • Piecing things together: “Cause for Alarm” by The Heavy
  • Research montage, pt.1: “Metrocenter 84” by Sunset Neon.
  • Research montage, pt.2: “You Rock Me” by she
  • Making a plan: “Drag and Drop” by the Soul Motivator
  • Showtime: “Swing Break” by the McMash Clan, feat. Kate Mullins
  • Showdown: “Mastermind” by Deltron 3030 and Dan the Automater
  • Showdown, cont’d: “Don’t Get In My Way” by Zach Hemsey
  • Roll credits: “UNLVD” by Socalled

Olives Fair in Love and War

  • Vampire fight: “Dark Entities” cover by Daniel Guerra Caballero
  • Roll credits: “Birdhouse in your Soul” by They Might Be Giants
0
submitted 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago) by andrewrgross@slrpnk.net to c/fullyautomatedrpg@slrpnk.net
 

I finally got around to making a playlist of the music used to score the starter campaign, Fully Automated: Regulation!

I think it's a collection of real bangers. I hope that for people who haven't played these stories, this might give an enticing taste of what to expect. And for people who might've played, perhaps it takes you back to some memorable moments.

Demonstration of Power

  • The stakeout: “This DJ” by Warren G
  • Fight scene!: “Dare to be Stupid”, covered by The Cybertronic Spree
  • Roll credits: “Fine”, by Lemon Demon

Psychonautica

  • Opening Sparing match: “Champion” by Buju Banton
  • Entering neurospace: “Just dropped in” by Kenny Roger
  • The mindscape: “Ghandi, Dalai Lama, Your Lord & Savior J.C.” by André 3000
  • Dance battle: “Do the Damn Thing” by Rupee
  • The Bathhouse: “Ants to You, Gods to Who?” by André 3000
  • Android assault: “Robot Rock” by Daft Punk
  • Synthesizing the cure: “The Oligo Separation Verse” and “Analytical Gangster” by True Speak
  • Roll credits: “Pony” by Deluxe

Piece of Mind

  • Surf Intro: “Cecilia Ann” by The Pixies
  • Fighting back: “Headshot” by she
  • Starting the investigation: “No Time for Dreaming” by Charles Bradley & Menahan Street Band
  • Sneaking around: “The Sensual Woman” by The Herbaliser
  • Piecing things together: “Cause for Alarm” by The Heavy
  • Research montage, pt.1: “Metrocenter 84” by Sunset Neon.
  • Research montage, pt.2: “You Rock Me” by she
  • Making a plan: “Drag and Drop” by the Soul Motivator
  • Showtime: “Swing Break” by the McMash Clan, feat. Kate Mullins
  • Showdown: “Mastermind” by Deltron 3030 and Dan the Automater
  • Showdown, cont’d: “Don’t Get In My Way” by Zach Hemsey
  • Roll credits: “UNLVD” by Socalled

Olives Fair in Love and War

  • Vampire fight: “Dark Entities” cover by Daniel Guerra Caballero
  • Roll credits: “Birdhouse in your Soul” by They Might Be Giants
view more: ‹ prev next ›