Parsani

Yeah the whistle was eerily similar

Oh I am as well. The proof provided in these videos is inconclusive and appear to point to different claimed misfires.

A different hospital strike?: https://twitter.com/ytirawi/status/1714720289769050117

edit: I think this one hit a residential building, but was filmed from the hospital

Yeah, the static 19:59 video doesn't show the second blast 2-3 seconds after the first like the AJ Arabic video does (but maybe it was obscured?), but it does show a second blast 12 seconds later. I wish the AJ Arabic video was continuous, because if it too showed another blast about 12 seconds after the first, it could be the same one.

What is quite odd though, is the difference between what the IDF videos are claiming and what the Israeli TV video is claiming, which I added after you commented:

The 18:59 timestamped video does not show the single rocket(?) depicted in the two videos the IDF posted, or in the 18:59 static shot. Maybe its too low quality to be seen, but odd nonetheless. The IDF videos seem to claim that this single rocket was the misfire, but the Israeli tv show seems to claim it was one of the rockets from the salvo.

The only video from the ground that I assume is true is the one shot through the gate: https://nitter.net/washingtonpost/status/1714406243652272340, and its too short and dark to see/hear anything else. I cannot hear a second blast within two seconds, which I am leaning towards as the correct sequence. The 19:59 timestamped video does not appear to have this second blast, so I am leaning towards it being a different event. Very odd how similar the times are though.

It is very dark that some of the proof being used to say Israel didn't bomb the hospital is "Israeli airstrikes cause way more damage"

Take a look at this: https://hexbear.net/comment/4122102

I've watched them several times, and am just more confused than before

Final edit: I do not think these two videos depict the same event. Still weird how such similar events happened exactly an hour apart.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/comments/17anen6/another_angle_of_the_hospital_explosion/ Timestamp: 19:59

https://old.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/comments/17an67c/video_by_israels_channel_12_showing_the_moment_of/ 18:59

Plus: The videos the IDF posted as proof: unsure of source: https://nitter.net/IDF/status/1714403025136017784 & AJ Arabic: https://nitter.net/IDF/status/1714442617201586220 show the time as 18:59.

Both videos claim to depict the same event. The first seems to strengthen the case it was not a misfired rocket, the second seems to strengthen the case it was a misfired rocket, due to where the rockets are fired in relation to the blast.

• The timestamps are an hour apart, and the camera (if it was the same one) had been moved slightly between them.
• It is too hard to tell if the pattern of rockets are the same as the 19:59 clip to so low quality
• Both show two explosions, but:
• the 18:59 has about two seconds between blasts. This is not shown in the video from Israeli TV, but is shown in the AJ Arabic video.
• the 19:59 video has about 12 second between blasts according to the timestamp
• Both videos show a salvo of rockets in the air by 18:59:10 & 19:59:10 AND the first blast happening at 18:59:20 & 19:59:20

The 18:59 timestamped video does not show the single rocket(?) depicted in the two videos the IDF posted, or in the 18:59 static shot. Maybe its too low quality to be seen, but odd nonetheless. The IDF videos seem to claim that this single rocket was the misfire, but the Israeli tv show seems to claim it was one of the rockets from the salvo.

I'm honestly losing my mind here. The difference in time between the two blasts leads me to think that the 18:59 video from Israeli TV and AJ Arabic are the correct ones, and the 19:59 timestamped video is depicting another event, but what the fuck are the chances that two rocket salvos happened EXACTLY an hour apart, and an explosion on the ground takes place EXACTLY an hour apart.

edit: I removed this, but I'm adding it back. Were there two cameras? One with its time incorrect? The timestamps are similar, but there are characteristics of the videos which differ. One has a light flare and lots of bugs flying in front, and more information on the bright area by the road. One has no light flare or bugs, and less information on the road.

Something which contradicts this would the the lights on in the windows on the building. In one, there is a light on on the building to the right which isnt in the other, and the timing between blasts. So I am leaning to the same camera an hour apart.

edit 2: AJ says it happened at approx 7:30pm ("At least 500 people were killed in an explosion at al-Ahli Arab Hospital in Gaza City at around 7.30pm on Tuesday"), which doesn't correspond to either timestamp.

Good find. I found alternates for both of the competing videos there. Different timestamps...hm

While I don't disagree, I'm leaning towards the video I posted being true as it was also on AJ Arabic from a different angle, but I don't think it is depicting what the IDF are saying.

This is the 2022 video: https://twitter.com/Sajjadca/status/1714377145794121940

IIRC that was a different video they released much earlier and then deleted, not the one I posted. They depict different things