Good argument could be made that Welsh Labour had very little fangs to begin with.
This is interesting, thanks for sharing.
You'd likely be surprised at how many people seem to think so.
Before I go through the answers I've already provided for you and pick out specific things so that you don't have to read through it yourself, will you agree to stop moving the goal posts here and actually engage meaningfully in this discussion, or is this ultimately just a waste of both of our times as you have your position, and you have zero interest in moving it? For the record, I don't mind if you have zero interest in changing your opinion, I would just like to know, so I don't waste more of my time.
Definitely agree with you there, Welsh Labour seem a little less tainted by the current direction the UK Labour Party is heading. Still too far right for my liking, though.
Worth noting I'm in favour of Independence though, so a unionist party doesn't inspire much hope regardless of colour.
As if we would ever work with those charlatans, absolutely laughable. Given how close Labour & the Tories are with their policy points right now, I would argue it's the rosette turning blue.
Yeah, no problem at all.
There is some debate around where exactly the talk of legitimate devolved powers for Cymru originated and indeed finished, but I would say that there are 2 documents you can pin it down to pretty well.
A white paper called: A Voice for Wales - https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/RP97-129/RP97-129.pdf
And the Government of Wales Act of 1998 (As it was enacted in 1998) - https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/38/contents/enacted
I was unable to find a free link for the white paper above, though the document I substituted it with, discusses it in great detail.
Both discuss devolution in great length, you should find what you're looking for here.
Yes, they did.
They may have lied, and I imagine quite a few of them did, but that was the line.
Supposed by whom, I cannot answer. I could describe what I believe is an almost ephemeral sense of what democracy in Cymru was 'supposed' to be, but I think that won't be answer enough for you.
As for sold by whom - Welsh Labour, UK Labour, Welsh & UK Conservatives, and the Liberal Democrats besides that. Democracy in Cymru is practically still in its infancy at this point, and it was sold to the people of Wales by the political parties of the UK that supported devolution back then, and those that support further devolution and even independence for Wales now.
Well, it's no secret that the current state of democracy in Cymru isn't what it was 'supposed' to be, or what it was sold as. I would argue it's not unreasonable to keep a hold of the vision of what democracy was promised to be, and by doing so referring to what we have currently as something that shouldn't be the way that it is.
I'm not naive enough to think that this is the best it gets for us, nor am I naive enough to think that meaningful change is right around the corner for us. I have no doubt the path to a healthier democracy in Cymru is a long one, but to give up on the very idea of it, is not something that I intend on doing.
I'm not sure what you mean about my life having any standing on what I think the author is trying to convey here? I'm not the author, I was merely suggesting what I believe the intended message was. I literally said that the state of things, in reality, is far from what the author is conveying.
Pretty much this, incredibly thankful that we have a genuine left-wing alternative in Plaid here in Wales. I genuinely feel for the English with their choices there.