It’s bullshit in that Hamas won’t be finished off. Both in a real sense in that there are many, many Resistance fighters who will survive and in the “how do you kill an idea” sense. The goal of Oct 7, I believe, was to break the Israeli sense of security and expose them for the paper tigers they are, and in that the Resistance has already been wildly successful. I do believe that regardless of the outcome of Rafah, Israeli civil society will tear itself apart. And whether that’s soon or off in the future, it’s gonna happen and when it does I believe the Resistance will be ready.
What is unfortunately true is that the IOF is going to commit further genocide in Rafah.
But let’s be real, “israel” knows they won’t end Hamas and I don’t think they even care. Their goal is to so deeply terrorize the population of Gaza that the people there never even contemplate rising up again. That, or they are just taking out revenge killings on civilians, probably a little of both.
While this particular brainworm affects not just Americans, it seems that white Americans seem to have the most acute case of it. And older Americans much more than younger ones. I think it has two main causes. One is that older, white Americans have basically had zero friction in their lives. They think everything will work out because everything has worked out pretty great for them. I think there’s also the thing at play here where these people don’t want to actually support policies that would help the situation, either because their taxes will go up or because that means they would have to support politics different from what they’ve supported their whole lives.
To extent that young people say this, I think it’s just a way to be polite without admitting that yeah shit sucks I don’t have any answers either.