AlolanVulpix

joined 3 years ago
MODERATOR OF
[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 4 points 3 months ago

This isn't about "laziness" at all - it's about structural barriers to voting that disproportionately affect certain demographics.

Research consistently shows that convenience voting methods like mail ballots and early voting help increase participation among:

  • People working multiple jobs or irregular hours
  • Those with caregiving responsibilities
  • People with mobility issues or disabilities
  • Residents in areas with fewer polling stations (often in lower-income communities)
  • Younger voters with less established voting habits

These demographics often (but not always) lean left, but that's correlation, not causation. The key point is that when we remove structural barriers to voting, participation tends to increase across diverse groups.

What's especially interesting is that under proportional representation, voter turnout is consistently higher across all demographics. When people know their vote will actually help elect someone who represents their values, they're more motivated to participate, regardless of party preference.

The real issue isn't about left vs. right, but ensuring our democratic systems provide equal accessibility for all eligible voters while maintaining security and integrity. With PR electoral systems, these concerns get addressed together - higher participation AND every vote counting toward representation.

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 4 points 3 months ago (4 children)

I agree with your assessment. The transparency and verifiability of paper ballots is a fundamental strength of our current system that electronic voting can't easily replicate.

The trust issue you've highlighted is crucial. Paper ballots create a physical audit trail that can be manually recounted by ordinary citizens. With electronic systems, we'd need to trust not just the code (which most citizens can't verify), but also the entire chain of custody of both hardware and software. As you noted, even with sophisticated cryptographic solutions, the public trust element is essential for democratic legitimacy.

There are also serious security concerns. Electronic systems create "single points of failure" that paper ballots distributed across thousands of polling stations don't have. Computer scientists and security experts have consistently warned about these vulnerabilities. See:

While I'm passionate about modernizing our democracy, I believe the focus should be on fixing the mathematical problem at the core of our electoral system - where millions of valid votes simply don't count. Electronic voting might change how we collect votes but doesn't address this fundamental democratic deficit.

Paper ballots with proportional representation would give us both the security benefits you've described and ensure every vote counts toward representation. That seems like the right sequence of priorities for strengthening our democracy.

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 6 points 3 months ago (1 children)

Great question! Fair Vote Canada (FVC) does have a broader mandate than just PR, though proportional representation remains their primary focus.

According to FVC's 2024-2027 Strategic Plan, they specifically mention "lowering the voting age to 16" as one of the democratic reforms they strategically amplify messaging around. So yes, they do advocate for this!

Their Vision, Mission and Values statement also notes that while PR is "the most fundamental and urgent change needed," they support a range of "democratic improvements which flow from our core values."

On electronic/internet voting, FVC doesn't seem to have an explicit position. This makes sense from a priorities perspective - while modernizing voting methods might improve convenience, it doesn't address the fundamental democratic deficit where millions of perfectly valid votes elect nobody at all.

Electronic voting also raises complex security and verification challenges. Any electronic system would need to uphold essential democratic principles including accessibility, voter anonymity, and verifiability. See:

Personally, I believe PR is the only viable long-term solution for ensuring every vote counts. Changing how we collect votes (electronic vs. paper) doesn't address the mathematical problem of winner-take-all systems discarding approximately 50% of ballots. But lowering the voting age to 16 would meaningfully expand democratic participation.

If you're interested in technology and electoral reform, you might consider getting involved with the proportional representation movement directly (particularly the List of social media accounts for Canadian Democracy) - we're always looking for volunteers with diverse interests and skills!

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 6 points 3 months ago

Conservative logic demands perfection from all other parties except their own, in which case, anything goes.

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 4 points 3 months ago (1 children)

Yes, FPTP forces strategic voting - but we don't have to accept this broken system! Our electoral system has changed before and can change again.

Every time we resign ourselves to strategic voting, we perpetuate the very system that forces us to vote strategically. It's a vicious cycle that only proportional representation can break.

Want a democracy where your vote actually counts? Join us: simple things you can do to grow the proportional representation movement.

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 2 points 3 months ago

I get it - strategic voting feels necessary under our current system. But this cycle of "holding our noses" every election is exactly what FPTP is designed to create.

With proportional representation, you could vote for who you actually believe in without fear of "wasting" your vote. Every vote would count toward representation - no more impossible choices.

If you're tired of this broken cycle, check out ways to grow the proportional representation movement so we can build a democracy where strategic voting becomes obsolete.

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 2 points 3 months ago

That's certainly a creative thought! While I appreciate the outside-the-box thinking, I think such an approach might actually undermine the fundamental principles that electoral reform advocates are fighting for.

The current ballot protest is designed to highlight how our FPTP system fails to provide meaningful representation. Creating deliberate confusion with identical names shifts from highlighting systemic problems to potentially interfering with voters' ability to express their actual preferences.

The goal of proportional representation isn't to break the current system through loopholes, but to build a better one where every vote genuinely counts. Credibility matters in this movement - we need to demonstrate that we're advocating for a more fair and functional democracy, not just finding creative ways to obstruct the current one.

That said, I do appreciate the energy behind finding ways to make electoral reform impossible to ignore! If you're looking for effective ways to advance this cause, check out Simple things you can do right now to grow the proportional representation movement. There are many constructive actions that can help us build momentum toward real change.

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 2 points 3 months ago

I completely agree with your assessment. This ballot protest is indeed a powerful yet peaceful way to highlight the fundamental flaws in our electoral system.

Your preference for proportional representation over ranked ballots is well-founded. While ranked ballots (IRV) might seem like an improvement, they're still a winner-take-all system that wastes votes. Under Single Transferable Vote (STV), you can actually have both ranked ballots AND proportional representation!

If you're looking to help advance the PR movement, check out: Simple things you can do right now, to grow the proportional representation movement

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 3 points 3 months ago

You're absolutely right - electoral reform truly is a gift to future generations. What we're seeing with the Longest Ballot Committee is just one creative expression of the deep frustration many Canadians feel with our current system.

The beauty of proportional representation is that it solves a fundamental democratic problem: in our current system, millions of perfectly valid ballots have zero effect on election outcomes. In the 2022 Ontario election alone, about 2.5 million votes (54% of those cast) elected nobody at all.

Democracy requires that every vote counts and affects outcomes. Anything less undermines the legitimacy of our government.

If you'd like to help grow the PR movement beyond ballot protests, check out this link: Simple things you can do right now, to grow the proportional representation movement - so we never have to vote for the lesser of evils, split the vote, or vote strategically again.

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 2 points 3 months ago

Yeah, that's frustrating. Login requirements are a barrier to participation and raise privacy concerns.

Still, the CBC giving electoral reform national attention is an opportunity we can't waste. If you're comfortable using Google, it might be worth the tradeoff just to show the CBC that proportional representation matters to Canadians.

Every chance to highlight how our current system discards millions of votes helps build momentum for PR.

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 1 points 3 months ago

That's awesome! These grassroots efforts are exactly how we'll build enough public pressure to finally get proportional representation. When everyday Canadians step up like this, it shows politicians this isn't just a niche issue - it's about the fundamental democratic right to have our votes actually count. Thank you for helping move us closer to a democracy where every vote matters!

[–] AlolanVulpix@lemmy.ca 1 points 3 months ago

That's really frustrating! Fair Vote Canada is mostly volunteer-run, but that's still a disappointing experience. If you're still interested in helping, maybe try reaching out directly to your local team coordinator through their website? Every volunteer effort helps build momentum toward finally getting PR implemented.

 

Alberta NDP on Bluesky

We’re building momentum, shaping our vision, and getting ready to defeat the UCP in 2027—and it all starts with you.

Join us next weekend in Edmonton for the 2025 Alberta NDP Convention!

#BetterIsPossible #BetterStartsNow #ABNDP

Register ⬇️

https://www.meet-here.ca/ABNDPConvention2025

Note that the ABNDP Convention 2025 is scheduled to take place: May 2 - 4, Edmonton Convention Centre.

 

Jagmeet Singh on Bluesky

I voted!!

Together we can create a Canada that works for everyone – a home you can afford, better health care services, and a bright future for our communities.

If you believe in this Canada, there’s still time to vote with us today.

Go to howyouvote.ca for more details.

Alt text: NDP leader Jagmeet Singh, wearing a pink turban and a light blue shirt, casting a ballot at an Elections Canada voting station. He has a grey beard and is carefully placing his vote into a white ballot box marked with the number 612. The voting location is a school gymnasium with yellow walls, blue and red banners in the background, and other voters visible around him. Singh appears focused and deliberate as he participates in the democratic process. Alt text: NDP leader Jagmeet Singh and a woman in a pink top walking past a bright yellow Elections Canada "VOTE" sign with an arrow pointing left. Singh is wearing a pink turban and light blue shirt, with a grey beard. The background features evergreen trees and autumn-colored foliage, with other voters visible in the distance. The scene is set on a sidewalk near a street, capturing the atmosphere of an election day.

 

Actually Akshay on Bluesky

Dropped off some more door-hanging flyers! Didn't see many folks this time, but every one of them was interested and learned about @fairvote.ca, so I'm feeling good.

Alt text: A Fair Vote Canada door hanger flyer with five colorful sections explaining the benefits of proportional representation. The top section reads "Why proportional representation?" with a subtitle "I want my vote to count, and I want my neighbour's vote to count. That's proportional representation." The sections are color-coded from top to bottom: Purple: "30% of the vote = 30% of the seats" with subtitle "That's fair!". Yellow: "Power is shared" with subtitle "No more 39% majorities!". Blue: "We can vote for what we believe in" with subtitle "Every vote will count!". Green: "Cooperative decision-making" with subtitle "For our future!". Orange: "We'll all have an MP we helped elect" with subtitle "Representation that works!". The flyer is being held by a hand against a background of concrete and grass. Alt text: A Fair Vote Canada informational flyer displaying a pie chart showing public support for proportional representation. The pie chart is predominantly blue, with 68% labeled as "Support", 19% as "Oppose", and 13% as "Don't Know". The top of the flyer features the Fair Vote Canada logo with a maple leaf. The text explains that under the current first-past-the-post system, a party can form a "majority government" with less than 40% of the popular vote. It emphasizes that a strong majority of Canadians support proportional representation and calls for MPs to work together to implement electoral reform. The bottom of the flyer includes a QR code and the website www.faivote.ca. The flyer is being held by a hand against a background of concrete and grass, with multiple copies of the flyer visible.

 

Longest Ballot Committee on Bluesky

Long ballots are an excellent and hilarious way to start a conversation about the importance of electoral reform in an era of growing authoritarianism but long ballots themselves are not unusual at all. Look around the world and you’ll see they’re actually quite common 😀

Euro Expat "It's cute you think this ballot is long. You should see what we have back at home" A long, narrow ballot for the 2024 European Parliament Election (Europa-Parlamentsvalget 2024) featuring Danish political parties. The ballot lists parties including Socialdemokratiet (Å), Radikale Venstre (B), SF - Socialistisk Folkeparti (F), Liberal Alliance (I), Moderaterne, Dansk Folkeparti (Ø), Venstre - Danmarks Liberale Parti (V), Danmarksdemokraterne-Inger Støjberg (AE), and Enhedslisten-De Rød-Grønne. The ballot is white and rests at an angle on a surface with a blue object and black garment partially visible in the background. A long, vertical German voting ballot being held by a hand. The ballot is extremely lengthy, with multiple columns of political parties and candidates numbered from 2 to 34. At the top left, there's a warning in German (ACHTUNG) about how to fold the ballot to prevent voter identification. Each party or candidate row has a circle for voting, and the ballot is positioned against a neutral gray background. A postal ballot with an extremely complex voting structure, held open by an older man with a reddish complexion. The ballot is so large it almost completely obscures his body, with only his head and hands visible. The ballot's instructions read "Please vote only in section 1 or section 2 (do not vote in both sections)" at the top, and in the middle it explains "Only number one box above the line OR You must number at least fifteen boxes below the line". The document is extensively detailed with multiple columns and rows of text, illustrating the complexity of the voting process.

 

London North Centre GPO/ London Centre GPC on Bluesky

Day 2 of advance polls from 9:00 to 9:00. Your Voter Information Card (VIC) has the location. If you didn't yet receive your VIC, check the Voter Information Service at: https://www.elections.ca/scripts/vis/FindED

Advance polls are also open on Sunday & Monday, same hours.

 

Mike Morrice🟢 on Bluesky

The lines were gone by mid afternoon yesterday and in minutes I was able to cast my vote at my advance polling location, Victoria Hills Community Centre. Thanks to all the good folks working this election that make this all possible!

To find your polling location, visit https://mikemorrice.ca/vote.

Mike Morrice, Green Party Member of Parliament for Kitchener Centre, smiling and wearing glasses, a flat cap, dark jacket, and blue pants. He is kneeling next to a bright yellow Elections Canada "VOTE" sign with an arrow pointing left. The incumbent MP is in a parking lot with a black van in the background, giving a thumbs up and appearing enthusiastic about voting at an advance polling location.

 

‪nam kiwanuka‬ on Bluesky

It was important to me to take my kids with me to vote today. I was born during a civil war in a country where people are still fighting for the right to vote. A short line to cast vote. Advance polling ends this Monday. Election day April 28th. For what you need to vote and where: www.elections.ca

Picture of Nam Kiwanuka with sunglasses in outside of an election office. Behind them is a sign with an arrow pointing the direction to vote.

 

Fair Vote Canada 🗳️🍁 on Bluesky

Alberta’s Transportation Minister wants to block a bike lane—in a safe opposition riding.

Under first-past-the-post, governments can ignore voters they don’t need to win.

Proportional representation means every riding, and every vote, matters.

#ableg #cdnpoli

Official letter from the Alberta Transportation and Economic Corridors, Office of the Minister. The letterhead features the Alberta Coat of Arms at the top. The letter is dated April 16, 2025, addressed to Karen Principe, Councillor of the City of Edmonton. The letter is signed by Honourable Devin Dreeshen, Minister of Transportation and Economic Corridors, expressing opposition to bicycle lane construction on 132 Avenue. The document is printed on official government letterhead with contact information at the bottom of the page.

April 16, 2025

Karen Principe, Councillor City of Edmonton 1 Sir Winston Churchill Square Edmonton, AB T5J 2R7 karen.principe@edmonton.ca

Dear Councillor Principe:

As Minister of Transportation and Economic Corridors, I am writing to express my concerns regarding the City of Edmonton's plans to construct bicycle lanes on 132 Avenue between 66 Street and 97 Street at the expense of driving lanes.

Transportation and Economic Corridors is working to ensure Alberta's roads meet evolving transportation needs. As our urban populations continue to grow, we need to seriously consider on how to maintain and increase capacity for motor vehicle traffic flow for current and future traffic needs, and not reducing capacity.

We are concerned with the impact to our provincial road network and its connectivity to the municipal roads. We are also concerned with future bicycle lanes and other lane-removal initiatives where taxpayer dollars are used to shrink, rather than increase road capacity for vehicles.

I strongly oppose this bicycle lane construction along 132 Avenue.

I encourage you to cancel or postpone constructing new bicycle lanes at the expense of driving lanes.

Sincerely,

[Signature]

Honourable Devin Dreeshen, ECA Minister of Transportation and Economic Corridors

 

Mike Morrice🟢 on Bluesky

Advance Polls are NOW OPEN. Find everything you need to vote at mikemorrice.ca/vote!

Picture of a sick kid with an ear thermometer. Picture of a car with a flat tire. Picture of a French Bulldog with a bandana in a veterinarian's examination room.

Sh*t happens. Vote Early. Advance Polls are open until Monday, April 21st, from 9 am to 9 pm each day. Find more information at mikemorrice.ca/vote. Need a ride? Call 226-614-1211. Mike Morrice: Green for Kitchener Centre

 

Fair Vote Canada 🗳️🍁 on Bluesky

Friendly reminder: the best strategic vote is for a candidate who supports proportional representation.

If enough are elected, we can change the system—and end strategic voting for good.

#cdnpoli #Election2025

 

Government That Works for You

Democratic Reform and Good Governance

The strength and integrity of our democracy is a core value. We believe that a truly democratic nation is one where every voice is heard, every vote matters, and public trust is honored. Our vision is to build a democracy that is transparent, accountable, and inclusive for all Canadians.

The Green Party will modernize Canada's electoral system by implementing proportional representation and convening a citizens' assembly on democratic renewal to examine crucial reforms like online voting, lowering the voting age to 16, and mandatory voting.

To protect our political system from foreign influence, we will restore the per-vote subsidy, reduce donation limits, and introduce a foreign influence transparency registry. We will empower Elections Canada to proactively investigate foreign interference and provide public reporting on threats to election integrity, including from emerging technologies like AI.

We must restore Canadians' trust in our democracy. That begins with transparency and integrity. Strengthening the Conflict of Interest Act to include personal, political, and family ties is essential, Canadians deserve to know that public service means serving the public, not private interests. A government with nothing to hide would close the revolving door between politics and lobbying, enforce real penalties for conflicts of interest, and shine a light into every backroom meeting.

We would implement real-time transparency in lobbying, and ensure all regulatory board appointments undergo meaningful conflict-of-interest screening. Whistleblowers must be protected, not punished. And our parliamentary watchdogs — the ethics commissioner and auditor general — must have true independence and the power to act. Ethics aren't optional, they're the foundation of democracy.

ELECTORAL REFORM

  • Modernize Canada's electoral system and protect Canadian democracy by implementing Proportional Representation.
  • Convene a Citizens' Assembly on Democratic Renewal to study proportional representation systems, lowering the voting age to 16, online voting, and mandatory voting.
  • Ensure the Citizens' Assembly is independent, diverse, and consensus-driven.
  • Require political parties to report on candidate recruitment from underrepresented groups.

POLITICAL FINANCE AND FOREIGN INFLUENCE PROTECTIONS

  • Restore the per-vote subsidy for political party funding and reduce donation limits to curb foreign influence in elections, strengthen financial transparency, and reduce reliance on private donors who may act as conduits for foreign interests.
  • Strengthen protections against foreign funding and influence in Canadian elections, including expanding third-party political financing rules.
  • Establish a Foreign Influence Transparency Registry, requiring individuals and entities lobbying on behalf of foreign governments to disclose their activities.
  • Expand the mandate of Elections Canada and the Commissioner of Canada Elections to proactively investigate suspected foreign interference.
  • Require political parties and candidates to report any known instances of attempted foreign influence or coercion.
  • Introduce public reporting on foreign interference threats in elections, balancing transparency with national security concerns.

CAMPAIGN INTEGRITY AND ELECTION OVERSIGHT

  • Require all political parties to submit campaign platform cost estimates to the Parliamentary Budget Officer.
  • Mandate Elections Canada to create a truth-in-advertising framework for election campaigns.
  • Empower the Commissioner of Canada Elections to regulate and sanction false political advertising.
  • Mandate full transparency in publicly released polls, requiring disclosure of sample size, weighting methods, funding sources, question wording, and margin of error to prevent misinformation.
  • Hold media and polling firms accountable for responsible poll reporting, ensuring all published polls are independently verified and presented with clear methodological context.

DEFENDING DEMOCRACY FROM EMERGING THREATS

  • Establish an all-party standing committee to examine the risks and opportunities of emerging technologies, including AI and digital platforms, in elections.
  • Oppose the pre-emptive use of the notwithstanding clause and support legislative measures to restrict its application, ensuring it remains a tool of last resort in exceptional circumstances.

ETHICS, CONFLICT OF INTEREST, AND LOBBYING REFORM

  • Strengthen the Conflict of Interest Act by broadening the definition of conflicts to include personal, political, and family interests, with meaningful financial penalties for violations.
  • Impose mandatory conflict of interest screening and disclosure for all federal regulatory board appointments.
  • Close the revolving door between politics and lobbying by enforcing a five-year cooling-off period for former politicians and senior public officials.
  • Enhance transparency by requiring lobbyists to publicly disclose, in real-time, all interactions with elected officials and public servants.
  • Expand whistleblower protections with robust safeguards against retaliation and secure channels for confidential disclosures.
  • Strengthen the independence and investigative powers of parliamentary officers, including the Auditor General and Ethics Commissioner.
  • Replace the secretive Board of Internal Economy with an independent oversight committee to transparently review MPs' salaries, expenses, and budgets.
  • Prohibit federal funding for industry-backed NGOs that advocate private interests under the guise of public benefit.
  • Mandate open government practices, ensuring proactive disclosure of government documents and timely responses to access to information requests.

RESTORING EXCELLENCE IN THE FEDERAL PUBLIC SERVICE

  • End reliance on costly private consulting firms such as McKinsey and Deloitte, ensuring that core governmental functions and services are delivered by professional, experienced public servants.
  • Reinstate effective, citizen-focused service delivery models, reversing damaging restructuring from previous governments, such as the creation of Service Canada under Harper.
  • Reinvest in Canada's federal public service, rebuilding capacity, morale, and expertise to deliver high-quality, efficient services that Canadians expect and deserve.
  • Enhance oversight and accountability to prevent misuse of taxpayer dollars.
  • Reduce wasteful spending at the political level, including significantly cutting the Prime Minister's Office budget from $10 million to $1 million

ACCESS TO INFORMATION AND GOVERNMENT TRANSPARENCY

  • Extend the Access to Information Act to the Prime Minister's Office, ministers' offices, and Parliament.
  • Scrap all Access to Information (ATI) fees except for filing fees.
  • Enforce deadlines for timely ATI request processing and empower the Information Commissioner to order the release of information.
  • Override government secrecy exemptions in the public interest.
  • Allow the Information Commissioner to review cabinet confidentiality claims.

PRIVACY, SURVEILLANCE, AND DATA PROTECTION

  • Expand Privacy Commissioner powers to protect personal data and enforce privacy laws.
  • Require CSIS and CSE to obtain warrants before surveillance on Canadians.
  • Ban routine surveillance of protestors and NGOs and prohibit data sharing with agencies like the National Energy Board.
  • Require internet service providers (ISPs) to release user data only with a legal warrant, except in emergencies.
  • Make political parties subject to the Privacy Act.
  • Mandate data breach reporting for all government agencies, companies, banks, and political parties.
view more: ‹ prev next ›