What pisses me off is when the online menu says market price.
I understand it reprinting menus every day is expensive, but if you are updating your point of sale terminals, you can type in the price into the online menu.
this post was submitted on 20 Jan 2024
61 points (89.6% liked)
Hacker News
4123 readers
2 users here now
This community serves to share top posts on Hacker News with the wider fediverse.
Rules
0. Keep it legal
- Keep it civil and SFW
- Keep it safe for members of marginalised groups
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
In what country is it legal for restaurants to say “market price” instead of showing the prices? So I can never go there?
Where is it illegal? I've seen Market Price listed for various menu items across the US.
across the US
Ah, that explains it. Over here in Germany, presumably the entirety of the EU and likelu most of the world this is not allowed:
Any business offering goods or services to consumers or advertising goods or services to consumers by stating prices must state the total prices.
§ 3 (1), PAngV
Of course, this isn't nearly detailed enough. That's why, for restaurants etc. the following applies:
The price lists must either be clearly legible at the time of the offer, displayed on tables or presented to each guest before orders are taken and upon request when the order is settled. A price list showing the prices of the main food and drink on offer must be displayed next to the entrance to the restaurant. If the restaurant is part of another establishment, it is sufficient to display the price list at the entrance to the restaurant section.
§ 13 (2), PAngV
Just listing the menu with "market price" would violate both these paragraphs. The following exists as well:
The prices listed in the price lists in accordance with sections 1 to 3 must include the service charge and all other surcharges.
§ 13 (5), PAngV
They will tell you the price when you are there and ask or if you call the restaurant. I've seen Market Price listed for fish and some more rare and exotic things like alligator and rattlesnake presumably because the price to the restaurant can change or the it could be based off the weight of a lobster or something like that.
It would be nice to have consumer protections in place like in the EU.
I’ve been to several countries in the EU and never seen a restaurant without explicit prices.
When I've seen it, the menu item was something like fish or lobster mostly, presumably because the cost to the restaurant can change as the prices as the market change and depending on the size of the fish or lobster. Otherwise, I've only seen it for rare/exotic meats like alligator or rattlesnake.
I mean for things like bottled water or soda, 'market price' should be fine. Those are commonly bought everywhere. Things available locally should mention the current price, can't expect guests to know trends.
Even for commonly sold items this practice is harmful to the consumer:
- difficult to prove someone wrong, even if their price is higher than usual
- easy to hide a higher price ("well, the local markets we shop at...")
- if the price isn't higher than usual, why hide it behind this
Information asymmetry shifts the power in any economic activities, and should never be encouraged.
Ah, now that's a straight up scam. Market price should directly mean the price 'printed' on it or the retail price. Anything else needs to be mentioned explicitly
Honestly, I actually quite like them.
Not for everywhere and every time, but for casual dining, it is very handy.
Replace them all with lemonparty.org qr codes.
What if I don't want to bring my god damn phone with me everywhere I go?
One day, I decided to not bring my phone when going out. What happened that day:
- I lost my debit card (I was too used to using cardless withdrawals from the ATM and forgot my card)
- My car picked a good time to break down in the middle of nowhere so it took me 6 hours before having a car passing by so I could get my car towed.
It's a miracle I didn't get murdered by a passing serial killer.
Not to be insulting: You'll be in the minority. Most larger cities have moved to this style in newer restaurants and many older ones since covid
Not that that doesn't suck because poor/homeless folks often cant afford or have a way to have a smartphone and keep it charged so no restaurants for them unless they take cash
If you have a QR code menu, you'd better have free wifi.
QR code restaurant menu = let's go to the next restaurant
see ya. More room for me
Sure, if I'm in Italy at some fancy restaurant, give me a nice menu to peruse. But most restaurants are turn and burn establishments that make money off volume and I don't want their dirty menu when I'm trying to get cheap happy hour food after work or quick lunch take out.
All the nicer restaurants I've been to either have physical menus as the standard, or it's a more "hip" place and they have them upon request.
This is weird how it's been such a cultural dividing line. It's like the last place consumers feel like they have any influence and are leaning hard into it