But they didn't confiscate his kitchen knives?
this post was submitted on 26 Jan 2026
199 points (99.5% liked)
3DPrinting
21110 readers
81 users here now
3DPrinting is a place where makers of all skill levels and walks of life can learn about and discuss 3D printing and development of 3D printed parts and devices.
The r/functionalprint community is now located at: or !functionalprint@fedia.io
There are CAD communities available at: !cad@lemmy.world or !freecad@lemmy.ml
Rules
-
No bigotry - including racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, or xenophobia. Code of Conduct.
-
Be respectful, especially when disagreeing. Everyone should feel welcome here.
-
No porn (NSFW prints are acceptable but must be marked NSFW)
-
No Ads / Spamming / Guerrilla Marketing
-
Do not create links to reddit
-
If you see an issue please flag it
-
No guns
-
No injury gore posts
If you need an easy way to host pictures, https://catbox.moe/ may be an option. Be ethical about what you post and donate if you are able or use this a lot. It is just an individual hosting content, not a company. The image embedding syntax for Lemmy is ![]()
Moderation policy: Light, mostly invisible
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Those probably have serial numbers and a whole tracking system lol
Did they take away his rocks too?
I don't get it, are knives illegal in Italy? What if I want to cut my spaghetti?
What if I want to cut my spaghetti?
This is the really weird thing. If these knives were made of metal and in a kitchen drawer, nobody would think of them as being weapons. But since they are 3d printed, that's novel enough to warrant some panic or something...
Not sure how rules are in Italy, but where I live "switchblades" and other one-hand operated collapsible knives are illegal.
Afaik, all single hand operation deployment knives are illegal in Italy. It's somewhat of a nonsensical rule when there are teenagers stabbing themselves with kitchen knives, but still...
You can make surprisingly sharp objects, I once cut myself with my printed bed-scraper by accident.
These printed knives can absolutely also be used to hurt/kill someone, if you wanted to...like all type of knives and basic cutlery really...these being an illegal type is the trigger here I believe.
Of course, I never intended to imply that a plastic knife would not be dangerous
It's not because they are 3d printed. He was distributing them at school! That is the problem.
If he were to file down toothbrushes and do the same he would still be arrested and his files confiscated.
Spring assisted switchblades are illegal in quite a few countries, so I imagine they are in Italy as well. Still completely ridiculous, as these are plastic toy replicas, and not actual knives.
Often even unassisted switchblades are illegal. They're called gravity knives.
Just to be pedantic, gravity knives aren’t switchblades.
They have a blade that slides freely (and under the force of gravity.) the grip is basically a hinged nutcracker that, when closed, traps the sliding blade either deployed or retracted.
In any case, they’re no more dangerous than your standard folding knives of the same general proportions.
The illegality of certain knives (switch blades, gravity knives, balisongs, etc) are largely not based on the danger or actual use of those knives as weapons.
In the US it’s usually reactionary and racism.
Gravity knives are considered switchblades in many jurisdictions.They aren't spring assisted switchblades. They are gravity assisted hence the name. Switchblade just means any knife you open with a switch or button. Don't take my word for it though, go read the first line of the wikipedia page on switchblades.
In any case, they’re no more dangerous than your standard folding knives of the same general proportions.
Often they are less dangerous since they can fail to deploy (especially an OTF spring assisted switchblade). I had a sweet benchmade switchblade when I was in the army but alas it got lost at some point. That knife was the best for one handed box cutting.
maybe instead go to the wikipedia page for 'Gravity Knife'
or just read my comment more fully. Gravity knives don't have switches. or buttons. If you're considering the hinge mechanism that allows a gravity knife to operate, then practically any folder is a "switch blade" and that's just not true.
from the wiki I linked:
A gravity knife is a knife with a blade contained in its handle, which opens its blade through the force of gravity. This mechanism of opening is fundamentally different from the switchblade...
Even in gravity knives that appear to be opened by a switch or buttons... all that button is doing is unlocking the blade to allow it to be deployed or retracted. If simply having a button or switch or something is all it takes to be a switchblade, then this classic gem would also be a switchblade.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switchblade
A switchblade (also known as switch knife, automatic knife, pushbutton knife, ejector knife, flick knife, gravity knife, flick blade, or spring knife)
Like I said, many jurisdictions consider gravity knives to be switchblades.
and many jurisdictions have laws written by people who don't have a frooking clue and are simply reacting to a knife being associated with whatever out-group happens to exist at the time.
What does that have to do with the price of tea in china?
My original comment said gravity knives are considered switchblades in many jurisdictions. Politicians being morons doesn't change that fact.
load more comments
(2 replies)
Like butterfly knives, many places in the us too. Ny for instance, cops are taught to flick knives open to be able to charge for knives no reasonable person would think fit the gravity description I read once.
load more comments
(3 replies)
Auto-translate is saying 'snap knife', but I'd imagine it's to do with it being deployable / spring loaded in some way.
Background: there was a student stabbed to death in Liguria (whole other place) and so media is going crazy about anything knife related.
The students were of Egyptian and Moroccan descent, so right-wing politicians are having a field day with the whole "culture war" shit
Poor guy even got his ams with four rolls of pla confiscated ☠️
I can't imagine getting a search warrant for toys in a teenager room.
3D printers are not really toys though, regardless of how ridiculous this arrest is. It's a tool, like a hammer or drill...nothing more, nothing less.
Hopefully someday these places make murder illegal so people can't kill others without violating the law.
Next we'll all see more legislation to make 3D printer software monitor everything you make and auto-report anything deemed dangerous to the elite
he printed some PLA shivs that would probably shatter if they hit a piece of parmesan cheese.
How big of a piece of parmesan are we talking? Ever tried to cut into a wheel of cold parmesan? It's pretty tough. Meatbags are a lot less tough.
That being said, we learned how to make knives by smashing a couple of rocks together like a thousand years ago, this ain't stopping nobody.
I can confirm it's much harder to stab a wheel of parmesan cheese than a person, but at least the cheese doesn't scream
I'm sure they'll be introducing legislation that makes owning your own means of production onerous if not illegal within a week or two. Can't be having citizens realize they can make their own replacement parts or consumer items!
There’s a little nuance here, the kid was dumb enough to bring one of those to school, so some worry is warranted… some. Now as you can imagine this is going to have consequences, but as we do have functional gun control laws, it’ll be something inane. Probably won’t impact 3D printing at all is the upside.
Italy is fairly rightwing and has been drifting more right over time. Don't underestimate their ability to not let a crisis go to waste!
Yeah, but we seem to like hampering the right to manifest, so I’m sure it’ll get thrown in the mix.
This guy will go to jail and start making knives for other inmates lol
That's performative. Sucks to be the student who will have his life ruined to be made "an example" out of.
The just d took a shortcut to filing a toothbrush. Those don't do shit a kitchen knife wouldn't do.
People who 3D print anime weapons replicas:
The swing speed on Guts' greatsword is so slow, the cops have plenty of time to unload 2 maybe even 3 magazines into them, so they're not as dangerous as the faster DPS weapons like daggers and shivs.
Yeah, but in this case it's less a sword and more a lump of plastic.
Those knives sure are dangerous
Hope they will soon ban these too and put their manufacturer in jail:
Well, I guess if I ever move to Italy I'll be screwed...
To be perfectly fair, a proper wheel of Parmigianino Reggiano IS quite hard...
Wow. Going after letter openers now, are they?
If you were to bring a letter opener to school and sell it to your friends you would still get a nice meeting with the police. The existence of the journal article is more related to the fact that a kid was stabbed to death in school last week, than to the fact that a dumb kid did something stupid and marginally related to his 3d printer.
Another murderbot off the streets. Italy is safe.
For now.
They need to ban printer sales
This is fucking dumb. I made a better knife than that on the bench grinder in my high school shop class. The teacher watched me do it (and immediately took it away).
Of course. One can make a better knife, or just take one out of a kitchen drawer.
view more: next ›