Terraria
I have so many world with Moonlord arenas ready to fight him, but my completionist anxiety prevents me from ever using them
Life Is Stange
I went in knowing the decision I would have to make at the end. Over the course of the game however, I realized that I didn't wanna choose either of the options. So I gave myself a third option: Don't finish the game. Now the characters all live happily in the limbo of incompletionism