RetroGaming

Persona 5 Royal

Dragon Age: Origins

Anti chamber, portal, journey, and Rez.

Silent Hill 2

SOMA

Morrowind is a good one too

Celeste is a good contender, Hades II as well.

Thomas Was Alone, The Fall, Rumu, To The Moon, Stanley's Parable, Toem, Primordia, Turing Test, The Entropy Centre, Subnautica, Bioshock 2, Portal 1/2.

Though honestly any game with good story would probably count here.

Hunt Showdown or Evolve

I would never do that. I'd just play it again.

Love...

I think MGS2 on the original PlayStation or PS2. That was a dream a few decades later.

Thief: The Dark Project

I still keep playing it with all the gfx patches, it's a masterpiece. 2 and 3 are not bad either, but the original is unmatched. Love the user generated mods as well.

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Blue Rescue Team and/or Explorers of Sky

@eru777 There are so many games I would love to do this with. I think possibly Ar tonelico 2 would be the one I might pick if I had to pick just one. It was just... so incredible. Story, characters, atmosphere, music (omg the music!) and just was so amazing and mind-blowing for me at the time. I was a bit torn between this one and Ar nosurge though. It too is just as incredible in its own way. (Biggest problem there is it's only available in English on the PS3, which is a system I technically own but hate. The recent Switch port has received absolutely no attention even from fans.)

But really there is just a whole host of things. I would wish more that I could erase memories one at a time then replay each one at a time.

League of legends because I hate myself

On a more serious Note Mischief makers is the only one that comes to my mind

Braid

Dark Souls

Edit: My bad, didn't notice the name of the community. I sure hope DS doesn't count as retro lol