A place to discuss Australia Politics.
This community is run under the rules of aussie.zone.
Be sure to check out and subscribe to our related communities on aussie.zone:
https://aussie.zone/communities
One of the few positions where I can agree with them. Anyone who claims to represent me in government shouldn't be swearing allegiance of a monarch.
The small protest did not disrupt proceedings, as it did when Victorian senator Lidia Thorpe gave the oath in 2022.
I'm glad the author added this line.
I'm glad the author added this line.
I can't tell, are you being sarcastic?
I'm being sincere, they compared it to a similar event to contrast the reaction.
Why was it so much of an issue for Lidia Thorpe? Hmmmm
Racism. The answer is racism.
Whoa, don't jump to conclusions, it could just be good old fashioned sexism, hard to tell sometimes
Oh it was defo both if not more.
Touché
Misogynoir
Hmm 🤔
Complete mystery, I guess we'll never know.
iirc she was acting like a massive twat during the whole thing, then she twated about with the King
https://youtu.be/18DCUS_ZNi4?t=28
and then she said proudly that she said the oath wrong (she swore an oath to the queens hairs not heirs or something) and then it became an issue
and this was after she had thrown herself down in front of the police at a pride festival and had gotten into a fight outside a pub
all in all, she was an attention seeking twat and got what she wanted...and then iirc in the end nothing happened same as katter
Good thing katter has a clean slate and definitely never did anything crazy or attention seeking.
I think you're forgetting how uniquely annoying she was being at the time, she quit the greens because she was voting no for the voice and relationship with biker gang ex-leader, never ending drama
uniquely annoying she was being at the time
Do you hear yourself?
never ending drama
I guess not.
what’s up?
Not much. It's a bit cold.
🥶 same! saw we were getting fog at the airport last night: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTO8n0Y6wgk&t=15027s
Oh, did she also try to weaken gun laws so her son-in-law could import automatic shotguns? How about suggesting that we conscript 13 year old and give them all guns? Maybe run a campaign ad that depicted her shooting rival politicians dead? I'm not a fan of Lidia Thorpe, but I think you're missing the point that the media routinely portrays Katters "antics" as that kooky old guy, but actively demonises Thorpe. They're both bloody annoying and crazy, there's just a narrative being pushed.
he’s been in parliament for like 50 years, she’d been in for like 1
if he acted like she did he also would have been blasted, same as bananaby joyce when he was the class nutter for a bit, same as pauline hanson when she was the class nutter for a while
you can posit some conspiracy theory or from my experience crazy politicians who do a lot of crazy things in a short time period will draw attention (just like how we’re talking about katter now)
iirc she was acting like a massive twat during the whole thing, then she twated about with the King
What a legend.
and then she said proudly that she said the oath wrong (she swore an oath to the queens hairs not heirs or something) and then it became an issue
Oh no a First Nations woman is protesting incorrectly. Call the protest police before somebody gets upset. Oh, oops too late.
all in all, she was an attention seeking twat and got what she wanted...
You know you come off sounding like a misogynist twat when you use the language of misogynist twats right?
You know you come off sounding like a misogynist twat when you use the language of misogynist twats right?
Could be worse, could come off sounding like Lidia Thorpe by thinking everything is racism and/or sexism.
I don't mind knowing lots of shit is racist and sexist instead of hating on a First Nations woman all the time.
Its the reason why he disapproves of Charles being king.
Conservatives have an incredibly stupid reason for their disapproval of Charles - it because they don't want Camilla, a divorced woman, to be queen.
Side note, these same idiots conveniently ignore the fact that Charles is also divorced.
Disgraceful! Send this criminal to Australia!
Um.wait...
Send him to Bradford!
Now that would be a inhuman punishment, wouldn't it? Show mercy!
It might be time for another referendum on this topic. However, given the chaos that has come out of the USA in the hands of a rogue government, I'd be hesitant to completely remove the role the monarchy plays in our government. We need that check on power and I don't know what you'd replace it with.
Monarchists are so weird lmao
I don't call myself a monarchist. But I am in favour of someone holding the power to send us to an election if we get a non-functional government. Whoever that is needs to be totally independent of our day-to-day politics and essentially un-bribable.
Right now, that's the king in England. I'm not against disconnecting from that - but like I said, I don't know where else you'll find someone who is outside daily politics in Australia and can't be bribed to act against our interests. If you have a name, I'm all ears (so is the king! 😆).
If you are proposing we just do away with that, then I'd love to know how you'd deal with an Australian Trump administration. Because 3-4 years of that doesn't sound fun.
Its not the King in England, its the GG here. She has the real power, the King only has a power to advise the Governor General and to a degree the Prime Minister.
Its important Australians, at least, realise that we very much are our own nation, subject to the same coercions and bribes that befall any middling nation such as ours, but at the end of the day we already have and use the power to shape our destiny.
Would there be an issue with that duty falling to the governor-general, perhaps making the position electable to someone who has no party affiliation? Just thinking off the top of my head. Totally expect everyone to point out all the flaws in this idea.
I think the US should become militantly anti-monarchist. We should make it a capital offense for any monarch, or anyone with an inherited title of nobility, to set foot on US soil. Banish the rats from the land.
We need that check on power and I don’t know what you’d replace it with.
it's elected idiots desire to become monarchy which leads to the problem. throw down your monarchy, chop off some heads, this desire to emulate them will evaporate overnight.
