The original post: /r/datahoarder by /u/azeGDV on 2024-08-26 23:04:21.
Hi all,
I've spent a lot of time researching how to best digitize my collection of PAL-M VHS tapes. I've consulted the Wiki here, searched through this sub, and looked at resources on DigitalFAQ, AVForum, HTForum (BR), and other sites. My main challenge is the lack of high-quality reproduction equipment, and I’m hoping to get some advice on the best capture device or workflow for my situation.
Source Material:
- All of my tapes are PAL-M VHS, recorded in SP (Standard Play) or EP (Extended Play) mode.
- The tapes are not in the best condition, showing signs of age, but they hold irreplaceable family memories.
Previous Attempts:
- First Attempt: I used a Dazzle DVD Recorder when it first came out in 2004. At the time, my computer was underpowered and lacked sufficient storage space, leading to disappointing results (at least as far as basic capture settings I seemed to be going in the right direction).
- Second Attempt: About 9 years ago, I hired a highly-rated company in Brazil to digitize the tapes. Unfortunately, the results were underwhelming—similar, if not worse, than my first DIY attempt, with visible interlacing and compression artifacts (see image below).
This is the 'professional' capture I paid for almost 10 years ago
Current VCR Availability:
- The VCRs I currently have access to are VHS-only models compatible with PAL-M—no S-VHS options are available.
My Goal:
I’m aiming to create a new, decent capture of these tapes—ideally my final attempt. Given the limitations (no S-VHS, older tapes), I’m hoping to achieve a result that closely resembles what you’d expect from watching these tapes on a standard TV: no persistent interlacing issues or noticeable compression artifacts, with the VCR making the necessary automatic tracking corrections during playback.
Looking for Advice:
Given these constraints, I’d appreciate any advice on:
- Capture Devices: Recommendations for a device that can handle lower-quality tapes and work well with my available VCRs.
- Workflow: Suggestions on the best capture process or settings to avoid common issues like interlacing and compression artifacts, given my equipment.
Thanks in advance for any guidance you can offer!