The original post: /r/datahoarder by /u/ostrichsak on 2024-06-24 15:54:30.
I just ordered some (6) retired data center 12TB HGST 12TB HDDs that are due to arrive tomorrow. I plan to test them for proper function and then deploy them in my DS920+ running SHR-2 (for 2-drive failure protection) and then the other two will go into external enclosures for 3-2-1 b/u use.
What I'm looking for is an inexpensive external HDD enclosure for this purpose. I want something that doesn't come with any need to hack firmware or other time consuming micro-managing that I don't want to deal with on a brand new product.
I've read that having a fan is a good idea. My network rack where this is going to be located maintains a consistent temperature below 65° so I'm not sure how important that is. Happy to hear input on if I should make this a requirement or not but it seems like it might be a good thing to have... less the added power usage and dust movement from something that may or may not actually be needed.
I've read that I also want something that has a physical power switch so it spins back up should power ever be lost. I don't anticipate this being an issue with my current s/u but if it's something that could save me headache should my set up change in the future I'd like to future-proof myself.
I also like the idea of something that isn't too large or has too many moving parts or anything to worry about for transport. My plan is to rotate one off-site weekly and I'm concerned about some that I've seen with big hinged doors and what not. Seems handy for quick access but I really don't anticipate swapping drives in and out of the enclosure often enough to make that a handy feature for this need. I think that the door popping open during transport would be more of a concern than a benefit.
All I really care about is performance. Something with a solid, reliably USB interface that nets top speeds for large data transfers from my NAS to the HDD is near the top of the list along with low price. I'm guessing I can fit the above criteria into something costing ~$20 but want to get something the community feels is trusted.
Thanks for the input!