Bug reports on any software 🐛🐞🪲

137 readers

8 users here now

When a bug tracker is inside the exclusive walled-gardens of MS Github or Gitlab.com, and you cannot or will not enter, where do you file your bug report? Here, of course. This is a refuge where you can report bugs that are otherwise unreportable due to technical or ethical constraints.

⚠of course there are no guarantees it will be seen by anyone relevant. Hopefully some kind souls will volunteer to proxy the reports.

founded 4 years ago

MODERATORS

freedomPusher@sopuli.xyz

Lemmy deletes your URL and replaces it with an image URL if you post a link then add a pic (lemmy.ohaa.xyz)

submitted 1 year ago by coffeeClean to c/bugs@sopuli.xyz

4 comments fedilink hide all child comments

This post was composed with a link to a Wired article:

https://lemmy.ohaa.xyz/post/1939209

Then in a separate step, the article was edited and an image was uploaded. The URL of the local image unexpectedly replaced the URL of the article. Luckily I noticed the problem before losing track of the article URL.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] hydroptic@sopuli.xyz 2 points 1 year ago (1 children)

Could maybe have a tabbed UI for a link post or an "image post". Both would essentially produce the same type of post but it'd possibly be less confusing?

It’s an implementation oversight, of course, because there is in fact no technical reason a post cannot have multiple pieces of information.

What does ActivePub say about this though? I honestly haven't looked into the protocol much at all (it seemed like a bit of a rabbit hole and everything's like RFCs and shit, ie. really technical and time-consuming to follow) so I don't know what sorts of limits it places on posts

[–] coffeeClean 1 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

Could maybe have a tabbed UI for a link post or an “image post”. Both would essentially produce the same type of post but it’d possibly be less confusing?

In the case at hand I posted an article, no image. Then I later returned to add an image. If there were a separate tab for posting an image users who add an image late might select the tab for image and assume their article URL is not lost but rather just not displayed in the image tab.

What does ActivePub say about this though?

Not sure. If the limitation is borne out of Activity Pub then Lemmy’s only easy fix is to make the limitation clear and also warn users of data loss. Alternatively Lemmy could hide the image URL in the body in a spoiler or something on exported data to enable recipients to render the thumbnail. If it’s a Lemmy-driven limitation then of course another fix would be to add a separate field.

Lemmy already has a protective popup feature for other situations. If you start writing a msg and then try to navigate away from the form, Lemmy asks “are you sure you want to leave?” So the same mechanism could be used for “are you sure you want to delete your URL?” if you try to initiate an image upload.