this post was submitted on 30 Mar 2026
5 points (69.2% liked)
Quark's
2081 readers
63 users here now
Come to Quark’s, Quark’s is Fun!
General off-topic chat for the crew of startrek.website. Trek-adjacent discussions, other sci-fi television, navigating the Fediverse, server meta (within reason), selling expired cases of Yamok sauce, it’s all fair game.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
It's hard to imagine a world in which writers are not allowed to express any harsh criticism of the work of other writers. I guess it would produce some really bad writing. If that's really how it works in American film and television, perhaps it explains a few things.
Are there a lot of fields where the professionals regularly tear into each other? Aside from politics, none come to mind.
Music
Heh, fair enough. Not sure I agree that recording industry beef is a model to be followed (and it would open up a whole 'nother conversation about how much of that is genuine), but fair enough.
Not just beefs. Artists and critics talk shit about music they don’t like all the time.
This stuff happens in creative fields. It doesn’t happen in other fields, because those generally involve tasks with predefined goals and ways of going about achieving them, and everyone is pretty much producing the same kind of output.
That's an interesting thing to bring into the conversation - Weir certainly isn't one.
He’s an artist
Everyone's a critic.
Law is a pretty adversarial field, though the tearing may mostly happen in the context of the practice itself.
Any sort of contest based profession usually has some large and clashing personalities that do some trash talking.
Scientists will go after each other's research if that counts. Dead fish MRI comes to mind.
Coding. "Who the hell wrote this crap code?" Checks blame. "Oh, me." See also Linus Torvalds mean phase.
Is he criticising mordern Trek though or basically just pushing the "its woke" nonsense narrative?
Like, there are critisims. Discovery felt incredibly out of place before they time traveled. Academy spent 4 of its 10 episodes on metaplot and ignored several of its characters (reminder, Tarima has a brother). All of it has too much "ThE gAlAxY iS At StaKe" overpowered plot constructs.
That is criticism.
Being angry they have gay Klingons is stupid.
Also I can only imagine his pitch.
"What if a white dude Starfleet Officer gets stranded in the Delta Quadrent alone and has to make poop potatoes alone to survive!".
Crossing my fingers it gets leaked 🤣