this post was submitted on 12 Mar 2026
231 points (99.6% liked)
Meshtastic
2207 readers
21 users here now
A community to discuss Meshtastic (https://meshtastic.org/docs/introduction)
Other mesh communities:
MeshCore: !Meshcore@feddit.org Reticulum: !Reticulum@mander.xyz
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Just note that many countries and cities are moving away from meshtastic to meshcore (same hardware, better protocol) due to scaling issues inherent in meshtastic
Australia is pretty much entirely meshcore apart from some abandoned derelict meshtastic nodes
I did see meshcore before I got into this stuff, but my issue is meshcore seems less resilient in lower density areas where there may not be many people investing in well positioned base stations. Almost all my typical use cases are very rural, where every possible node contact matters, and I do not have the money or physical access to set up enough of my own good base stations.
Meshcore nodes can all repeat messages now for the very circumstance you describe
This was a recent enhancement
...interesting... well, good thing it all uses the same hardware haha
However, if you are militant about open source, meshtastic is the only way to go, because for about a year, all the mesh core interface apps were closed source proprietary crapware, and some of the firmware for some of the devices is also proprietary.
I hope at some point, both will do interop. Its causing a bit of a splintering of the community...which really doesnt need to happen (mostly on discord and reddit from what I have been seeing). We are so small to begin with. And its not the devs doing it, it seems to be the community themselves. Which is again unfortunate.
Yeah, I'd say the only good thing is the fact that the radios can be flashed to either one of them very easily, so you're not locked into one or the other.
Very true!
Yeah that's also a good point. I am sort of half militant about open source, for something as independent as a mesh network I definitely prefer it. I'll stay on meshtastic for now I think.
Honestly, I'm getting more and more militant about open source. The longer things go on and I see the crazy shit that companies are trying to do.
For example, I've been running LineageOS on my phone without Google Play services since 2018, because I don't want anything to do with the Google Play Store. But the fact that Google is now trying to keep all Google certified devices from installing third-party applications, what's to stop them from bringing that to AOSP in the future? So now I'm seriously looking into getting a Linux smartphone, even if it's not quite ready for daily driving yet.
I've been perfectly happy with lineage, but now I'm seriously looking into PostmarketOS. I'm perfectly aware that it's going to be rough for a while, but somebody has to take the plunge and be willing to smooth out some of the rough edges for others.
Me too. It all started when I switched to Linux...lol
I'm very close to biting the bullet and getting a cheap Linux phone.